Does Flute Material Actually Matter? The Truth Every Player Should Know
- Reesa Myers
- 2 days ago
- 6 min read
This one is generally up for debate. Some flute players will tell you the material your flute is made of makes all the difference in the world, while others will say it's just a way of getting you to buy the more expensive flute.
I'm here to tell you that there are differences in what your flute is made out of, but it may not be in the way you think.
If you're in the market for a new flute, you might notice that the flutes are made from different metals and wood. Is a gold flute really better than nickel silver? Are wood flutes better than silver flutes?
Flute Materials
First, let's take a look at what all the materials of flutes are made of and why a flute would be made of this metal, wood, or something else.
Plastic/composite
Yes! There are flutes made out of plastic and composite flutes, and you'd be suprised in how they sound. Plastic flutes such as the Nuvo flute or composite flutes like Guo, even have their differences.
Nuvo Flutes:
The Nuvo flutes are known for beginners. Think of your middle schooler (or even younger child) learning an instrument... think of how rough they can be with just their things. The plastic flute can withstand a rougher player. If the plastic flute is dropped or hit against the stand, it's stronger than a metal flute. Plastic flutes are also lighter in weight so your child doesn't struggle to hold it as much. And surprisingly, the plastic flute sounds very similar to a regular flute! The downside to the Nuvo flute is the keys are a little clunkier. Fine for beginners and for a quick practice; not ideal for an advanced student about to get on stage for a recital.
Composite Flutes:
Guo considers their flute a composite flute, which is a blend of materials; polymer and resin. The Guo flute feels more like a regular flute, though still lighter in weight. It's not as thick as the Nuvo flute. The Guo flute also surprisingly sounds good. I'd recommend the Guo flute more to adult players though. It has a bigger price tag but has a better response. The Guo flute is a great choice for someone who has a metal allergy or for someone who needs a practice flute. Unlike the metal flutes, you can leave the Guo flute out on a stand, which promotes more practice (if it's already available, more than likely, you'll pick it up and play at least a quick scale a passage you have memorized).
White Copper/Cuppernickel
Alright, I'll be honest with you. White copper or cuppernickel can really ruffle some folks' feathers; it all depends on who you ask. White copper, also known as cuppernickel is a blend of metals; usually copper, nickel, & zinc. The tricky part with these is that you don't know the percentage of blend. Our own Musician's Addition Student flute is made of white copper. Flutes found on Amazon are also made of white copper. I can tell you that not all of the white copper/cuppernickel flutes are not the same. Using a blend of metals allows the flute to be at a cheaper cost, but that also means the flute may not be as strong as other metal flutes. Does this mean these flutes are terrible? This will depend on who you ask. From my experience, some are terrible, but that's between their metal bend and how they are put together in the factory. Here's where it's you get what you pay for. I bought a good hunk of these flutes. The cheaper they were, the worse they were. And honestly, flute tech's and repair guys hate these instruments because they are harder to work with. BUT, there are some flute repair techs that will repair them if needed. Your bigger companies will not touch white copper flutes.
Ok, so now let's talk sound. In my opinion, as long as it's a better-made flute, they can sound really good. If it's a really cheap one, they are harder to get a sound and can be airy.
Now you might be wondering about the Musician's Addition Student Flute in White Copper. It is a budget-friendly flute, but it's not the cheapest of the White Copper flutes. I am still playing on our tester flute, which I got in 2023. As of today (April 2026), it's still playing just like new! I had several repair techs take a look at our flute to get their opinion on the flute and the consensus was this flute is well-made and well put together. If you take care of your flute, it'll be good to you. I'll have to see how long it can last (can it last as long as these 100 year flutes? Maybe not, but it might be able to get you until you're ready to upgrade your flute). One thing to note, if you are considering this flute for your middle schooler, middle schoolers are rough on instruments, even if they don't mean to. I had one particular middle schooler who was playing on the Musician's Addition Student Flute, and the way she was putting the flute together and taking it apart was too rough for this flute to withstand... (I'm talking to our flute maker about making a nickel silver flute for those who need a stronger metal. Stay tuned!) With that, we have had several students play on this flute for a couple of years with no problems.
Nickel Silver
Nickel Silver (many times it's marked Silver-Plated) is the standard material made for beginner flutes. The Nickel Silver is very durable (but not indestructible) and easier for flute repair. These flutes have great tone and are beautiful, though they can tarnish. Tarnish doesn't affect the sound; it just makes your flute look dirty.
When shopping at big-name stores such as The Flute Center of New York or Flutistry, their beginner flutes are nickel silver. Many of these flutes, with proper care and maintenance, can last for YEARS. The nickel silver flute will cost more, though.
Here's what my first flute sounds like (last repair done to it was 2000. This flute was made in 1972)
Solid Silver (Sterling Silver)
Ok, now we are getting into the intermediate and professional flutes. Why switch metals as our skills progress? Now it comes down to tune. With a sterling silver flute, you get a warmer, richer, tone. I find that I have more control dynamically with a sterling silver flute. If you are one a budget but need to upgrade your flute, this is the material you'll get. At this level, do not get a white copper intermediate flute. Those are no good at this level.
If you're in the market for an intermediate or professional flute, this is where you'll want to budget and try out different flutes. Between the different brands and mechanism choices, trust me when I say not all these flutes feel, play, or respond the same. Take the time and find the flute you'll love!
Gold
Gold flutes are only offered as a professional flute. Now this is where people start debating. Some people will tell you that the sound is more powerful, more resonant, and warmer. Some people will tell you it's a marketing ploy. I tried out a gold flute myself. Don't get me wrong, I REALLY enjoyed playing this flute, but if you had me listen to recordings of a sterling silver flute versus a gold flute, I don't know if I'd be able to pick it out. Gold flutes have the option of 9k, 14k, 18k+. Most gold flutes are handmade as well. You'll see a lot of professional flutists play with a Gold flute, and though the metal is softer, they are way more expensive, and harder for repair techs to deal with, many professional flutists are able to produce the sound they are looking for and love the feel of their gold flute.
Platinum
Believe it or not, some flutes are made out of Platinum. These are the most expensive flutes and are only made at the professional level. Platinum is best known for being able to project sound, but it's a much heavier metal. I've never played a Platinum flute to give you my thoughts. These are rarer.
Wood
I found that the wood flutes were fun to play, but their maintenance and care kind of scare me. The wood flute felt like it needed more air and interestingly, the flute does have a heavy smell of wood (maybe that's because I was playing a new one. Not sure if the smell goes away over time). Wood is more sensitive to condensation and temperature, so it requires more care. They also need to be oiled by a repair tech to help avoid cracks. Wood flutes would not be a good choice for marching band. Wood flutes are generally made for intermediate players.
So Does Flute Material Actually Matter? Which one should you get?
This all comes down to your skill level, budget, and your personal preference. Most students get the silver-plated flute. Amateurs and intermediate players will get sterling silver. Professionals, we'll see some gold. And sometimes we'll see players with a wood flute.
If you're picking out your favorite, which would it be? Let me know in the comments!
Comments